This article discusses how an ethnic-based federation has destroyed national identity and economic prosperity. Since the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) introduced ethnic federalism, Ethiopia has operated under a pernicious principle: “Oromo First, Amhara First, Tigre First, Somali First.” This ethnic cancer is slowly destroying the country. Ethiopian identity exists only as a cover for extracting benefits or fulfilling bureaucratic obligations. National identity has been subsumed by ethnic allegiance. Countries with characteristics or constructed like Ethiopia never last long enough to see daylight.
The current conflict in Welkite, the conflict with FANO, many other killings and displacements, and the war between TPLF and the Federal government in November 2020 are primarily ethnic driven and the result of the TPLF constitution. Ethiopia’s landlocked status was facilitated by TPLF. This shows the decline of nationalism and the rise of individuals driven by hatred towards Ethiopia and ethnic interests. TPLF assumed that it could align itself with Eritrea and that making Ethiopia landlocked was no concern. After more than 30 years of conflict, divide and rule, killing, and displacement, the Ethiopian people are yearning for sustainable peace and economic development.
The Foundation Metaphor
The system invites destabilization. External enemies understand this vulnerability. Egypt and Eritrea manipulate Ethiopia’s ethnic fault lines with ease. Ethiopia operates as a plaything for regional powers because its constitutional structure stands against national interest. Historical enemies use this leverage all the time. Ethiopia, despite being endowed with so many resources and people, is being played like a toy or at the mercy of Egypt, Eritrea, even tiny Djibouti, and others because of these factors.
Disintegration or Continuity
Ethiopia has a similar characteristic to countries that eventually implode and disintegrate, and the shiny objects built with the sweet and labor or borrowed money get destroyed. Countries that lack national identity or are assembled using religious factions, like Lebanon, or countries assembled using ethnicity or nationalities, such as the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, Czechoslovakia, like Ethiopia, disintegrate. Since the introduction of ethnic federation by TPLF, the mantra or the motto is Oromo First, Amhara First, Tigre First, Somali First. This continues to overshadow Ethiopian identity.
In his Seminal book “Wax & Gold”, Donald Levine talked about Ethiopian mendacity, or their willingness to pretend to be Amharas, Tigres, whoever is ruling at the time, to fit or survive, with identity switching. This psychological harm is only inflicted in Ethiopia by the system. The psychological damage is tremendous and a constant threat to the well-being of all Ethiopians. The economic damage is even more serious, as it has the potential to retard the flow of investment and knowledge. Constant conflicts, policy paralysis, and corruption are symptomatic of ethnic federalism.
Article 39 of Ethiopia’s constitution grants every ethnic group the right to secession. Ethiopia stands alone among nations in codifying its own potential dissolution. Friends and foes like Uganda’s Museveni, Rwanda’s Kagame, and even Eritrea’s Isaias Afwerki—have advised against such constitutional suicide. Yet Ethiopia persists with a structure designed for fragmentation rather than unity, despite the lesson from failed states.
Economic and Tourism Loss: Morocco as a mirror:
I was fortunate enough to be in Morocco during the Africa Cup of Nations (AFCON) with my family. It is not about the games that I want to talk about, but Morocco itself. Ethiopia and Morocco have similar cultural and geographic characteristics, except that Ethiopia has a longer history and more internationally recognized monuments. Despite that, Morocco’s per capita income is several times higher, $5150 compared to $1070 for Ethiopia. In 2025, Morocco attracted close to 20 million tourists, generating nearly $14 billion; in contrast, Ethiopia’s tourism receipts was a tiny $1.1 billion.
Ethiopia’s Tourism Goldmine —Underperforming
Ethiopia sits in one of the most extraordinary tourism value propositions: unparalleled antiquity, millennia-old civilizations, dramatic landscapes, and climates ranging from alpine to semi-tropical. Lalibela’s rock-hewn churches, the towering obelisks of Aksum, the imperial palaces of Gondar, and the birthplace of Lucy — the oldest known Homo sapiens ancestor — not only represent deep historical value but global brand recognition that most countries spend billions to buy. Yet Ethiopia’s tourism sector generates a fraction of its potential. Contrast that with North African and Middle Eastern peers, and the gap is not just striking — it’s economically damaging.
Another factor I observed was that Moroccans have a
strong sense of nationalism and security. They carry their flags proudly, women can move around day or night at any corner of the country without fear, and children play freely on the streets or in the parks. The police are present in strategic areas, and instead of being feared, they are respected and seen as protectors of peace. Tourism requires security. Investors demand stability. Neither exists under ethnic federalism. Morocco chose national unity. Ethiopia chose ethnic division. Morocco attracts development, Ethiopia attracts conflict. The picture shows Singer Jassar kissing the Moroccan flag.
Ethiopia’s resources and population should command regional respect. Instead, the nation endures constant humiliation because ethnic federalism has made it ungovernable and weak. External forces do not need to invade. They simply need to fund the ethnic faction most opposed to the current leadership and watch Ethiopia tear itself apart.
The Path Forward: Constitutional Reform or National Dissolution
Ethiopia stands at a critical point. The nation can either reform its constitutional structure or accept gradual disintegration. Any other assumption defies all historical evidence. There is no middle ground. Ethnic federalism will destroy Ethiopia just as surely as it destroyed other nations.
First, Article 39 must be abolished. No nation can survive with constitutional provisions for its own dissolution. Granting secession rights to ethnic groups guarantees perpetual instability as factions position themselves for potential independence. Unity requires commitment, not escape clauses.
Dismemberment or divorce by consent, as we seen in the former Soviet Union, or by force, like we have seen in Somalia, is messy. It’s not worth contemplating as the already misery index of Ethiopians would be much higher.The Urgent Call to Action: The nightmare TPLF initiated must end now. Every day, ethnic federalism weakens national bonds and strengthens ethnic identity. Morocco’s success demonstrates what unified nations can achieve. Ethiopia can choose the path of national renewal or continue toward fragmentation. The nation possesses every resource necessary for prosperity except political will for unity. Without constitutional reform that abolishes ethnic federalism and rebuilds national identity, Ethiopia will join the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, and Czechoslovakia in the graveyard

